|
Dear Fair Traders,
It is with great sadness that I forward you this message about
the tragic deaths of 14 Mexicans who dehydrated in the scorching
desert while trying to cross the Mexico-Arizona border last week.
This tragedy adds to the over 1500 people who have perished since
the beginning of Operation Gatekeeper, the deadly policy of extreme
militarization of the US-Mexico border.
This message was front page news last week - but there's a new
twist. In this case, the situation is directly related to the
price of coffee and the dire need for Fair Trade Not Free Trade.
Rob Collier's Chronicle article last week reported that thousands
of Mexicans from Chiapas are leaving their homes to search for
better opportunity because of low coffee prices. Check out the
bottom of a later AP story pasted below:
"Family members in the poor, highland villages of Veracruz
said the immigrants were seeking a better life after plummeting
coffee prices left them no other choice but to illegally enter
the United States to look for work." Enclosed please find
a background article on the tragedy as well as the AP story which
makes the coffee connection.
****************************************************************************
Devastating Picture of Immigrants Dead in Arizona Desert
New York Times May 24, 2001 By James Sterngold
ELLTON, Ariz., May 24 -- Local and federal officials painted
a devastating picture today of a smuggling operation that killed
at least 14 young Mexican immigrants in Arizona, saying a "coyote"
had apparently abandoned more than two dozen men in one of the
country's most brutal and desolate stretches of desert on Saturday
with little water and no preparation. A dozen who survived the
ordeal, in 115-degree temperatures, were in a hospital in Yuma
today. One of them, a 16-year-old, was in critical condition.
Though dozens die every year trying to cross illegally into Arizona
from Mexico, this was the area's worst single incident in memory.
In 1980, 13 illegally immigrating Salvadorans died in Arizona.
Border officials said today that in years of patrolling this
region they had rarely found immigrants in such desolate surroundings,
many of them more than 30 miles from any road or structure at
a time when the heat had shot up. Every year, more than 100,000
immigrants are caught crossing the border illegally near Yuma
but usually on better marked and less dangerous routes. Some relief
groups organized by churches have set up water stands at popular
crossing points, jugs of water marked by blue flags, but none
were near the place where the latest deaths occurred, Border Patrol
officials said.
"It was dirt, some rock, just a few small trees," said
Sheriff Ralph E. Ogden of Yuma County, who added that the temperatures
on the desert floor had risen to close to 130 degrees.
"They did not appear to have any water when we found them,"
Sheriff Ogden said. "Some had torn off some of their clothing.
The bodies we found were already decomposing."
The dead were found in clusters miles apart. The group had apparently
split up after traveling about 30 miles north from a Mexican truck
stop just across the border. This morning two more immigrants
were found, one dead and the other barely alive. Border Patrol
officials said agents were tracking what they thought was one
more person heading east -- perhaps one of the coyotes, or smugglers,
or a guide.
Mexican consular officials said at a news conference in Yuma
today that the Mexican police were questioning a suspected smuggler
in Mexico but had made no arrests. The Mexican authorities said
they thought other men had been involved and were searching for
them.
All of the latest victims were male, apparently between the ages
of 16 and
35. All were from Mexico, the officials said, and at least some
had come from the state of Veracruz.
They were found spread across an area that included the Barry
M. Goldwater Air Force Range and the Cabeza Prieta National Wildlife
Refuge, southeast of Yuma. Border Patrol officials said that they
had not had a chance to question all the survivors but that typically
they would have paid their smugglers more than $1,000 each. In
this case they appeared to have been led to a remote stretch of
the fence separating the two countries and then told to head north
to Interstate 8. The highway is about 70 miles from the border.
Twenty-six people died in the border sector near Yuma in the
fiscal year that ended Sept. 30, and four more died in the region
before this incident, said Maurice Moore, a Border Patrol spokesman.
The officials said this smuggling operation could not have produced
any other result.
"There's not much around there except the sand and bushes
with thorns on them," said Glen Payne, the agent in charge
of the Border Patrol office here, which found the first of the
dead and dying men during a routine patrol yesterday morning.
"There's nothing for like 30 miles in any direction."
The initial sighting was about 10 a.m. Wednesday, about 30 miles
north of the border. Four men were found badly dehydrated, and
they told agents that 22 others were behind them. Just before
1 p.m., 17 people were found just to the south by a Marine helicopter
crew, which airlifted them to a hospital. Ten were already dead,
and one more died before the helicopter landed. At 1:45 p.m. two
more bodies were found about 11 miles farther south. Then, at
5.a.m. today, two more men were discovered, about four miles south
of the first sighting. One had already died. The other, the 16-year-
old, was near death but made it to a hospital, where he was in
intensive care. Doctors at the hospital said that even the healthiest
of the men would probably be in the hospital at least a week and
that they all might suffer permanent kidney damage.
Many people involved in trying to ease the tough conditions at
the border said today that they were outraged at the loss of life,
with some arguing that federal policies to stanch the flow of
illegal immigrants near urban areas, a Clinton administration
policy, Operation Gatekeeper, had led to such deaths by pushing
the illegal border crossers to more and more remote areas.
"We knew this was coming," said Isabel Garcia, a lawyer
in Tucson and a co-founder of the Arizona Border Rights Project,
an umbrella group of 60 organizations that assists immigrants.
"We've been forewarning, lobbying, begging, cajoling, protesting,
shouting, praying. We've done everything to bring attention to
this very deadly law enforcement strategy that has been used by
the border patrol of driving people into the most remote areas,
where they have to know this will occur."
Jay Michaels, a ranch manager in southeastern Arizona, said that
people in his region were shocked by the news and that he was
putting water and relief supplies at remote spots on his ranch
for any immigrants who might be wandering across the land.
"What you hear people around here saying is that these are
not illegal immigrants, they're humans, and we have to treat them
that way," he said. Johnny Williams, regional director for
the Immigration and Naturalization Service, said rescuers had
searched an area the size of Delaware. "If you haven't been
to that area and you want to know what isolation is, go to this
corner of the desert," Mr. Williams said.
Over all, deaths along the United States-Mexican border have
increased about fivefold since the operation began in 1995. Last
year, the deadliest on record, more than 400 people died crossing
the border with Mexico, and so far this year there has been about
one death a day.
"Today's headline in the Tucson paper said, `Desert Kills
12,' " said the Rev. Bob Carney, pastor of St. Luke's Roman
Catholic Church in Douglas, Ariz., which provides sanctuary to
illegal immigrants and places water at remote paths used by immigrants.
"I believe that it is our policy that killed them, and that
this is a failed policy."
Mr. Williams rejected that assertion and said federal officials
were doing everything possible both to protect the border and
protect the illegal immigrants, particularly from ruthless smugglers.
"What is the common ground is smugglers," Mr. Williams
said.
"It's one of the most horrible deaths that can occur for
a human being," he added. "It's a grisly, terrible,
terrible death."
|